PB 14:14 Day 13 – The Arrival

With just two more picture books to review in the Picture Books 14:14 Challenge, I’m going to pull a bold move and review… not a picture book.  Technically a graphic novel for its length and paneled illustrations on some pages, The Arrival has one of the most beautiful, wordless depictions of plot I’ve ever seen.

The Arrival 1Title: The Arrival

Author & Illustrator: Shaun Tan

Publisher: Arthur A. Levine Books, 2007

The Arrival is the story of an immigrant traveling to a new land to find a better home for his family.  He leaves his wife and child behind in their home country, where the illustrations hint at the shadowy evils of oppression, and packs their photo into his one suitcase as he ventures off to brave life in a foreign territory.

The author’s portrayal of the characters experiences in a new land hit closer to home with my own time living abroad than any other book I’ve encountered.  His uncertainty through the complicated immigration procedures, his bafflement and mistakes with the different language, currency, and appliances, his isolation and longing for his family, his wonder at the beauty of the land and culture, the kind strangers who reach out to him, and the slow process of his assimilation are so real.  Yet the new land in the book is completely imaginary, filled with fantastical creatures and inventions so that readers of any background can relate to the foreignness of it.

The Arrival 2

The pacing of the plot through the pictures also helps us to fully experience every action in the story’s plot.  Some of the pictures are full two-page spreads, filled with intricate detail for us to take in all at once, like the overwhelming feeling of standing in a new place, surrounded by all kinds of beauty as well as ugliness that you have never seen before, for the first time.  On other pages, there are multiple small panels just to show a short scene.  A full page shows twenty frames of the character’s hands hovering over a conveyor belt to show the redundancy of his factory job.  Others show his range of facial gestures and hand motions as he tries in frustration to communicate.The Arrival 3

Although the book is long because of how fully the author portrays the plot, his use of wordless illustration allows you to breeze through it or linger on every experience.  It never drags… at least no more than life drags when you find yourself in a place where you don’t yet feel like you belong.

If you enjoyed this book, I also highly recommend Tales from Outer Suburbia, another of Shaun Tan’s incredible graphic novels.  I’m not a big graphic novel reader, but these are two of my very favorite books in the world.




Filed under Picture Books

5 responses to “PB 14:14 Day 13 – The Arrival

  1. I’ve read a review and seen the images from this book in another post or somewhere…it IS a well-done graphic novel. The big change as a challenge, with the thread of multiple challenges, leads you on and on through the MC’s journey. Great example.

  2. Thanks! I whole-heartedly recommend it…

  3. Wow! I have to read this! We are a nation of immigrants, but so many people forget that. I’ve taught ESL here and when I see how much people have given up to come here, often just thinking of being able to help their families back home, it really moves me. I wish more people would put themselves in the shoes of immigrants and consider what they would do if they couldn’t provide for their families instead of being so quick to judge. I’m very intrigued by this book and love the spread of hand gestures you describe — I remember my mom and husband communicating in those when he first moved here!

    • Thanks, Lindsay. This book is such a universal story of immigration. I think you would really connect with it! And I completely agree with you – with the huge majority of our society today coming from a family of immigrants somewhere along the way, you’d think we could be more welcoming and understanding of other immigrants. The author had a really nice quote about hoping to build some empathy with the book: “In Australia, people don’t stop to imagine what it’s like for some of these refugees. They just see them as a problem once they’re here, without thinking about the bigger picture. I don’t expect the book to change anybody’s opinion about things, but if it at least makes them pause to think, I’ll feel as if I’ve succeeded in something.”

  4. Packing up and moving to a new country has many challenges other than the language. I know first hand. And those that are doing it to escape from a bad situation must often leave everything behind. Not an easy thing. This sounds like a good book to help explain the plight of many refugees.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s